Warning: fopen(/home/virtual/kcse/journal/upload/ip_log/ip_log_2024-05.txt): failed to open stream: Permission denied in /home/virtual/lib/view_data.php on line 100 Warning: fwrite() expects parameter 1 to be resource, boolean given in /home/virtual/lib/view_data.php on line 101 Introduction of the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences exam to Korea and its significance

Introduction of the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences exam to Korea and its significance

Article information

Sci Ed. 2015;2(1):35-37
Publication date (electronic) : 2015 February 28
doi : https://doi.org/10.6087/kcse.35
Korean Council of Science Editors, Seoul, Korea
Correspondence to Eun Jung Kim  kcse@kcse.org
Received 2015 January 28; Accepted 2015 February 4.


In October 2013 and September 2014, the Korean Council of Science Editors (KCSE) organized the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences (BELS) certification examination in Korea. The total number of BELS examinees was 30 in 2013 and 27 in 2014. They comprised of domestic and foreign editors, manuscript editors, society staffs, and librarians. Nine of the examinees (2 in 2013, 7 in 2014), six of whom were Koreans, passed the exam. I had worked for preparation of these exams for two years as a general manager of KCSE. I would like to describe the process up to its introduction, exam registration process, and the significance of implementing the first BELS examination in Korea.

The Board of Editors in the Life Sciences Certification Examination

In the early 1980s, ten editors, who were responsible for the editorial and publication functions in various organizations, came to an agreement that there was a need for a program that would strengthen the professionalism of editors by evaluating their editing abilities, and hence enhance the quality of academic journals. With this in mind, they developed a qualification certification program and, with the establishment of BELS in 1991, conducted the first BELS certification examination [1]. The BELS examination is a holistic evaluation of the professional knowledge in the fields of life sciences, English proficiency, and manuscript editing proficiency. Applicants are required to solve 100 to 110 multiple-choice questions within three hours, and must achieve 65% or higher to pass. From 1991 to 2014, there had been 148 BELS examinations. Those exams have contributed to improve the professionalism of over 1,200 manuscript editors in 23 countries in the field of life sciences (personal communication with Leslie Neistadt).

Motivation for Implementation of the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences Examination in Korea

KCSE launched in September 2011, with the goal of “promoting the quality enhancement of scientific journals and contributing to scientific and technological development.” The KCSE started educating journal editors as the first step towards enhancing the quality of academic journals; furthermore, it realized that the role of manuscript editors was also quite significant in enhancing the quality of journals. In spite of this recognition, there was a considerable short of professional manuscript editors at the time. In 2012, this situation prompted Sun Huh and Hye-Min Cho of the KCSE to devise a method to encourage manuscript editors to become professional ones. They came up with a plan to launch the implementation of the BELS certification examination in Korea.

The BELS examination was originally created in response to the same kind of concern that the KCSE had. The certification exam has been developed through several evaluation processes, consistently managed, and taken for over 20 years. It was eventually established as an internationally recognized exam. However, this examination was provided usually for editors in Europe and in the United States in the editors’ or manuscript editors’ conferences. Out of Asian countries, India is only one country where BELS exam was opened. There was no opportunity for Korean editors to get familiar with the exam. Since there was an increase of need for professional manuscript editors. The KCSE anticipated that implementing the BELS examination in Korea would be a good opportunity to enhance the professionalism of manuscript editors.

Process of Implementation of the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences Exam in Korea

Sun Huh and Hye-Min Cho began to discuss how to implement and conduct the BELS exam in Korea through email conversations with Leslie Neistadt, the secretary general of the BELS. As a part of the approval process for implementing the exam in Korea, the BELS imposed the condition that there should be at least 20 applicants for the exam. KCSE immediately attempted to count the number of applicants. However, since even the name of the exam was not familiar to Koreans, it was difficult to estimate how many would be willing to take the exam. KCSE decided to organize a meeting to explain the purpose of the BELS examination to editors and manuscript editors. In the Editors’ Workshop held in September 2012, where many editors, manuscript editors, publishers, and society staffs and employees of publishing companies attended, Leslie Neistadt was invited as a speaker. She gave a talk titled “What kind of committee BELS is, with what history, why and how the BELS examination was established, and what is needed to take the exam.” A survey was done after her speech to see how many people would be willing to take the BELS exam if it were conducted in Korea. Exactly 20 of the attendees were willing to take the exam, which led to the confirmation that the first BELS exam in Korea would be performed on October 19, 2013. Once the date was fixed, the KCSE established an eight-week manuscript editors’ intermediate level education course in preparation for the exam. The course attendees were editors, manuscript editors, and those responsible for editing academic journals, who fulfilled the eligibility requirements for taking the BELS examination. The curriculum content was the subject matter of the expected BELS exam questions, as set out in the “topics tested” outlines in the BELS study guide. The subjects covered grammar, punctuation, statistics, unit of measure, scientific terms, and publishing requirements. The KCSE invited tutors for each part of the course. They had taught the examinees for two months prior to the exam.

Registration to the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences Exam and Taking the Exam

Eligibility requirements and exam processes were explained in detail. The registration period for the BELS exam is up to two weeks before the exam date, and applicants were permitted to take the exam only upon successful registration. Applicants must meet all the eligibility requirements before they can register. Those requirements are a bachelor’s degree or higher and at least two years’ editing experience.

In addition to the application form, BELS requests some supplementary documents during the registration in order to assess whether applicants meet these eligibility requirements. A copy of a certificate of graduation or report card must be submitted to satisfy the first criterion. Three letters of recommendation from the editor of a relevant academic journal, a fellow editor at work, and his or her employer must be submitted to satisfy the second criterion. The application form can be downloaded from the BELS home page [2]. There is no set template for documents other than the application form. Documents must be written in English and be submitted to a BELS officer by mail or email, along with 50 US dollars for registration. It takes about a week for confirmation of successful registration, so it is preferable to register in advance. If the applicant receives a registration form from BELS after submitting documents, he or she is eligible to take the exam. The registration form is not available to the public on the BELS website. The likely reason for this is to enable BELS to maintain control over who is eligible to take the exam. Upon receiving the registration form, applicant must fill out the form and submit it to BELS, along with the fee of 200 US dollars. Once the registration is confirmed, BELS sends the applicant an admission slip and a receipt (Fig. 1). The application fee of 50 US dollars and the registration fee of 200 US dollars are payable through mail transfer, credit card payment, or wire transfer.

Fig. 1.

Registration process for the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences (BELS) exam.

First Board of Editors in the Life Sciences Examination Held in Korea

On October 19, 2013, thirty applicants gathered at the Seoul Center of College of Medicine, Hallym University to take the exam. BELS officer checked the test papers and reorganized the seating plan. Ten minutes before the start of the exam, the examinees, who were sitting in the waiting room, were asked to move to the exam room. Their admission slips and identification documents were verified when they entered room. Before the exam began, a BELS officer explained the caution during the exam. Once all the examinees sat down, the three-hour BELS exam officially began. Thirty examinees successfully finished the exam, two of whom passed (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2.

Photo celebrating the first group of Board of Editors in the Life Sciences examinees in Korea (October 19, 2013).


By implementing the BELS examination in Korea, I can learn more deeply about manuscript editing and professionalism of manuscript editors. This is significant since it creates a pool of human resources needed to improve the level of manuscript editing in Korea. It is also an opportunity to demonstrate that manuscript editors are important professionals whose expertise has been validated through professional training and education. When much number of academic journal editors demand their services, they will be able to contribute to the development of scientific, technological, and medical journals from Korea. Furthermore, BELS exam in Korea will provide more opportunities for editors in other Asian countries to get familiar with the BELS exam. Ultimately, it could be the cornerstone for enhancing the quality of Asian science journals.


No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.


This work is supported by a grant from the Korean Council of Science Editors (2013).


1. Board of Editors in the Life Sciences. About BELS [Internet]. [place unknown]: Board of Editors in the Life Sciences; 2006. [cited 2014 Dec 15]. Available from: http://www.bels.org/about/index.htm/.
2. Board of Editors in the Life Sciences. Application [Internet]. [place unknown]: Board of Editors in the Life Sciences; 2006. [cited 2015 Jan 26]. Available from: http://www.bels.org/becomeeditor/applicationform.pdf.

Article information Continued

Fig. 1.

Registration process for the Board of Editors in the Life Sciences (BELS) exam.

Fig. 2.

Photo celebrating the first group of Board of Editors in the Life Sciences examinees in Korea (October 19, 2013).