1Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, Indonesia
2Research Center for Science, Technology and Innovation Policy & Management, Indonesian Institute of Sciences, Jakarta Selatan, Indonesia
3Deputy for Life Sciences, Indonesian Institute of Sciences, Jakarta Selatan, Indonesia
Copyright © 2021 Korean Council of Science Editors
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
1975 | 2000 | 2005 | 2006 | 2011 | 2014 | 2018 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Regulatory | Unknown | Guidelines for Submission of Proposals for Accreditation of Scholarly Journals in 2000 | Regulation of the Head of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences Number 01/E/2005 concerning Guidelines for Accreditation of Scientific Magazines/Journals | Decree of the Director-General of Higher Education, Ministry of National Education Number 11/DIKTI/Kep./2006 about Scientific Accreditation Guidelines | Regulation of the Head of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences Number 04/E/2011 about Guidelines for Accreditation of Scientific Magazines/Journals | Regulation of the Director-General of Higher Education Number 49/DIKTI/Kep/2011 | Regulation of the Head of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences Number 3 of 2014 about Guidelines for Accreditation of Scientific Periodicals | Regulation of the Director-General of Higher Education Number 1 of 2014 about Guidelines for Accreditation of Scientific Periodical Publishing | Regulation of the Minister of Research, Technology and Higher Education of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9 of 2018 about Accreditation of Scientific Journals |
Institution responsible for scholarly journal accreditation | Indonesian Institute of Sciences | Directorate of Research Development and Community Service, Directorate General of Higher Education, Ministry of National Education and National Accreditation Board | Indonesian Institute of Sciences | Director General of Higher Education, Ministry of National Education | Indonesian Institute of Sciences | Director General of Higher Education–Ministry of Education and Culture | Indonesian Institute of Sciences | Director General of Higher Education–Ministry of Education and Culture | Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education |
Scope of scholarly journal accreditation | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of R&D institutions | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of higher education | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of R&D institutions | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of higher education | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of R&D institutions | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of higher education | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of R&D institutions | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of higher education | Scientific magazines/journals published within the scope of R&D institutions and universities |
Elements of scholarly journal accreditation assessment | Content and substance of the publication | Name of periodical (5), institutional publisher (5), editor (30), stability of appearance (10), style of writing (10), substance (25), periodicity (12), and post-publishing obligations (3) | Name of periodical (5), institutional publisher (13), editor/editorial board (12), stability of appearance (9), writing style (11), substance (28), periodicity (10), circulation (5), and others (7) | Periodical name (5), publishing institution (5), editing (21), appearance (9), writing style (11), substance of content (36), periodicity (10), and post- publishing obligations (3) | Substance (36), editor and reviewer (17), writing style (15), publishing institution (9), periodicity (8), appearance (8), additional services (4), and naming (3) | Name of scientific periodicals (3), publishing institution (5), editing (18), appearance (8), writing style (13), substance of content (40), periodicity (9), and dissemination (4) | Name of scientific periodicals (3), institutional publishers (4), editing and management of publications (17), article substance (39), writing style (12), appearance (8), periodic (6), and dissemination (11) | Name of scientific periodicals (3), publishing institutions (4), editing and management of publications (17), article substance (39), writing style (12), appearance (8), periodicity (6), and dissemination (11) | Name of scholarly journals (3); publishing institution (4); journal editing and management (17); article substance (39); writing style (12); appearance (8); periodicity (6); and dissemination (11) |
Scholarly journal accreditation classification | Scientific, semi-popular, and popular science, as well as a mixture of the three | Accredited fair (C) 60–69; accredited good (B) 70–79; and accredited very good (A) 80–100 | Accreditation A (80–100), accreditation B (70–79), accreditation C (60–69), and not accredited (<59) | Nationally accredited scientific periodical rank A (>85), nationally accredited scientific Periodical rank B (70–85), and unaccredited scientific periodicals (<70) | Accredited scientific magazines/journals (≥70), unaccredited scientific magazines/journals (<70) | Nationally accredited scientific periodical rank A (>85), nationally accredited scientific Periodical rank B (70–85), and unaccredited scientific periodicals (<70) | Nationally accredited scientific periodical rank A (>85), nationally accredited scientific Periodical rank B (70–85), and unaccredited scientific periodicals (<70) | Nationally accredited scientific periodical rank A (>85), nationally accredited scientific Periodical rank B (70–85), and unaccredited scientific periodicals (<70) | Sinta 1 accreditation (85 n≤100); Sinta 2 accreditation (70 n<85); Sinta 3 accreditation (60 n<70); Sinta 4 accreditation (50 n<60); Sinta 5 accreditation (40 n<50); and Sinta 6 accreditation (30 n<40) |
Indicators | Quality |
|
---|---|---|
Management | Substance | |
Journal title, aims, and scope | 3 | - |
Publisher | 4 | - |
Editorial and journal management | 17 | - |
Quality of articles | - | 39 |
Writing style | - | 12 |
Format of PDFs and e-journal | 8 | - |
Regularity | 6 | - |
Dissemination | 11 | - |
Total | 49 | 51 |
Based on [